Low Number of Trades but Big Gains? The CRA Might Be Watching
It’s a question that’s been buzzing in the trading community: How much trading activity (or profit) gets you flagged by the CRA? If you’ve had large gains in the stock market—even with only a handful of trades—you could find yourself under the watchful eye of the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).
People wonder "do I have to pay taxes on day trading" and the answer is "it depends". If you're a professional day trader, your day trading income could be classified as business income and could be fully taxable at your personal tax bracket (marginal tax rate). Also, if you have day trading losses, those losses could be fully tax deductible against your other income.
Recently, I came across a lively Reddit discussion where traders and investors shared their experiences. The thread was filled with questions, anecdotes, and expert insights into how the CRA might treat your trading gains—whether as capital gains or business income. Let’s break it down.
The CRA doesn’t publish a clear-cut rulebook for what defines a day trader or when they’ll review your trading activity. But here are some common factors shared by the Reddit community and other tax experts:
One Redditor mentioned hearing that the CRA considers over 240 trades a year as a sign of day trading. However, this number isn’t found anywhere in CRA guidance. It’s likely an unofficial benchmark floating around, based on one trade per workday minus holidays.
Another user highlighted that even if you make only two trades a year but rack up massive gains (think $1 million+), the CRA is likely to review your return. The CRA isn’t necessarily interested in frequent trading that generates no profit—they’re looking for big earners who might be misreporting their gains as capital gains when they should be reported as business income.
The CRA focuses on your intent when assessing whether your trading income should be taxed as capital gains (50% taxable) or business income (100% taxable). Are you holding securities for long-term growth and dividends, or are you flipping them for short-term profits?
If trading is your primary source of income, or you have professional experience in finance or investing, the CRA might view you as running a trading business, even if your trade volume isn’t particularly high.
People wonder "do I have to pay taxes on day trading" and the answer is "it depends". If you're a professional day trader, your day trading income could be classified as business income and could be fully taxable at your personal tax bracket (marginal tax rate). Also, if you have day trading losses, those losses could be fully tax deductible against your other income.
Here are a few key takeaways from traders who’ve shared their experiences online:
The CRA could use a holistic approach to determine whether your trading activity qualifies as capital gains or business income. Key factors include:
The CRA will also consider the portfolio turnover rate and how your trading compares to your overall income. If your trading generates significant profits compared to other sources of income, expect closer scrutiny.
If you’ve had significant trading gains, there are steps you can take to avoid issues with the CRA:
Maintain separate accounts for active trading and long-term investments. Report active trading as business income and investments as capital gains to clearly show your intent.
Keep detailed records of your trades, including your reasoning for buying or selling. If audited, this documentation can help justify your position.
If you’re making significant gains, get advice from a CPA or tax expert who specializes in investment income. They can help you structure your filings to minimize the risk of a CRA challenge.
The CRA doesn’t audit everyone—it focuses on cases where there’s potential for significant reassessments. Still, having good documentation and being prepared is better than being caught off guard.
Canadian taxes rely heavily on self-assessment, but with big profits come big responsibilities. If you’re making significant gains in the stock market, understanding how to properly report them is key to avoiding trouble with the CRA.
Remember, the CRA isn’t just looking at your number of trades—they’re assessing intent, frequency, and the nature of your activity. Whether you’re a casual investor or an active trader, take the time to report your gains correctly and keep your records in order.
For more information, consult Canada.ca and if you’re looking for a CPA in Ottawa, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
This is not legally binding tax advice. This is educational analysis. Say hello if you need help.
WhatsApp - 613.600.4194
--
Disclaimer
The information provided on this page is intended to provide general information. The information does not take into account your personal situation and is not intended to be used without a specific consultation. Lucas CPA Professional Corporation will not be held liable for any problems that arise from the usage of the information provided on this page.
